How to Set Up a Group Benefits Plan for Your First Employee
Hiring your first employee can be exciting and nerve-wracking. After all, you were a one-person army, and now you are taking on an added responsibility and cost.
However, to grow, hiring is a must. It is an essential milestone for any business owner and a sign that your business is growing.
However, finding a suitable first hire is easier said than done. Apart from the qualities you want from an employee, you also need to consider what that employee would want from you.
Key Takeaways:
- Bespoke flexible tax-advantaged benefits like QSEHRA or ICHRA are ideal for smaller businesses with 1-10 employees
- A budget of approximately 1.25 to 1.4 times salary is needed to include group benefits that comply with local and federal law
- Retirement perks like SIMPLE IRAs or MEPs are also great options that offer competitive benefits with low administrative costs
- Digital tools and PEOs make setup, admin, and compliance a whole lot easier
Why Group Benefits Matter for Your First Hire
According to a study published by OMHRA, 80% of Canada’s workforce considers group benefits when evaluating job opportunities.
However, a survey conducted by Abacus Data for Medavie Blue Cross found that 80% of SMEs in Ontario, Quebec, and Atlantic Canada did not provide their employees with group benefits.
This shows a sizable gap in the market and one that fledgling businesses can exploit.
But what type of group benefits plan would be best suited for your first employee? What options do you have, and can you afford them?
Let’s break it all down.
Understanding the Benefits Landscape for Small Employers
SMEs in Canada generally have the following options when it comes to group benefits:
- QSEHRA: Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement is an IRS-approved health benefit plan designed specifically for small employers. This plan allows employers to reimburse employees for eligible healthcare expenses and individual health insurance premiums on a tax-free basis.
- ICHRA: Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement is another specialized group benefits plan that allows small to medium-sized employers to reimburse employees for individual health insurance premiums and other qualified medical expenses tax-free.
- Traditional group insurance is the most common form of employer-sponsored benefits plan in Canada. This type of plan offers uniform coverage, often including disability insurance, life insurance, medical, dental, and vision care.
- PEOs: Professional Employer Organizations, or association group plans, provide comprehensive human resources services for SMEs. PEOs can handle all types of HR functions, including payroll processing, benefits administration, compliance, and workers’ compensation, minimizing the administrative work for small employers.
In today’s competitive labor market, employees place value on group benefits that include dental and vision coverage, free mental health services, life insurance, and wellness perks like gym memberships or therapy.
Top-tier talent also looks for benefit packages that offer financial support tools (budget coaching, RRSP matching), virtual care, and telehealth.
These “extra benefits” aren’t just dangling carrots. Employees value these added perks. As a small employer, providing these extra benefits can help you stand out in the market.
Choosing the Right Group Benefits Plan
Let’s break down each plan for further clarity and more informed decision making:
| Plan Type | Best For | Key Features | Downsides |
| QSEHRA | Very small teams | Reimburses employees for personal insurance and expenses, tax-free | Annual contribution limits |
| ICHRA | Teams with mixed employment types | Customizable by role or department; no contribution cap | Complex admin |
| Traditional Plan | Larger or growing companies | Group health insurance, often bundled with dental, vision, etc. | Higher premiums for small teams |
| PEO or Association Plan | Microbusinesses wanting scale | Shared HR and benefits services | Less flexibility in plan design |
TOP TIP: If you are setting up a group benefits plan for your first employee, QSEHRA is often your best and most budget-friendly option.
Steps to Set Up a Group Benefits Plan for Your First Employee
Setting up a group benefits plan is a 3-step process.
- The first step: Choosing the type of coverage and plan you want to offer your employees.
- The second step: Determining what type of benefits would be most attractive for the type of employees you want to hire.
- The third step: Determining cost and deciding what benefits to offer and which ones to forgo.
Having a strategy in place is therefore essential. The best way to come up with said strategy is to consult with a trusted insurance broker that specializes in benefit plans for SMEs.
If that’s what you seek, call Pat McIver at 1-902-220-3279 or click here to book a free, no-obligation 30-minute consultation.
Budgeting for Benefits
The real cost of an employee isn’t just their paycheque. As an employer, you are also responsible for their physical and mental well-being.
Group benefits can help take care of that and can give you and your employee much-needed peace of mind.
But what does it cost?
For a small employer, setting up a group benefits plan can cost about 1.25 to 1.4 times an employee’s salary. Here is a simple formula to give you a ballpark estimate.
Total compensation = Employee Salary + 25% to 40% of salary in benefits
This added percentage can help cover a range of benefits. Below is a table that helps break it down.
| Benefit Type | Estimated Annual Cost |
| Health & dental (QSEHRA or pooled) | $2,000–$4,000 |
| RRSP or retirement match | $1,000–$2,500 |
| Life/disability insurance | $200–$500 |
| Wellness/mental health | $200–$600 |
Employers can also choose to share benefit costs with their employees. For example, an employer can offer to pay 50% to 80% of the premium costs and let the employee pay the rest through payroll deductions.
Remember, HRAs are tax-free for your employee and tax-deductible for you.
Legal Compliance and Regulations
Compliance and regulations also play an important role when setting up a group benefits plan.
Canadian employers must stay compliant with:
- Federal and provincial employment standards
- CRA rules for tax treatment of benefits
- Any specific licensing or plan rules under ERISA, ACA, or HIPAA if you’re hiring cross-border
As an employer, be sure to:
- Outline eligibility (e.g., full-time, part-time, contractors)
- Set waiting periods if needed (usually 30 or 90 days)
- Provide all required notices and paperwork
- Always document how your plan supports equity and inclusion
Retirement Plan Options for Microbusinesses
While retirement plans were once unattainable for SMEs, today, Canadian small businesses can tap into a range of retirement plan options, including:
- SIMPLE IRAs: Individual retirement accounts that are easy to set up and have low admin costs
- RRSP Group Plans that offer tax-deferred savings for employees
- Multiple Employer Plans (MEPs) that pool admin and compliance, making them more affordable
The Secure Act also makes it easier for small employers to offer retirement benefits without taking on huge responsibilities.
Here is a table that outlines the ease of setting up a retirement plan for your first employee.
| Plan Option | Employer Contribution | Setup Time |
| RRSP Match | Optional | 1–2 weeks |
| SIMPLE IRA | Required match or % of pay | 2–3 weeks |
| MEP | Pooled plan across employers | Depends on provider |
Employee Communication and Onboarding
Providing benefits is one thing, but if your employees aren’t aware of them or don’t know how to use them, what’s the point?
This is why communicating benefits is so important, especially when onboarding your first hire. You need to:
- Walk them through the full compensation package
- Explain each benefit in plain language
- Provide a simple FAQ or one-pager with links and contact info
- Talk openly about mental health, time off, and how to access support
Growing with Flexibility and Scalability in Mind
One employee today could mean five by next year. Pick plans that grow with you.
Ask yourself:
- Can this platform add users easily?
- Can I offer different benefits to different types of employees?
- Can I adjust the budget or coverage as things change?
Only choose a plan that ticks all relevant boxes and check in regularly to make sure the chosen plan still makes sense.
Don’t be shy to ask for employee feedback, review plan usage, or explore new options like:
- Telemedicine (like Maple or Akira)
- Wellness spending accounts
- Financial literacy tools or coaching apps
Group Benefits Plan for Nova Scotian Employers
Setting up a group benefits plan doesn’t have to be complicated or costly.
With tools like QSEHRAs, pooled retirement plans, and digital admin platforms, even solo employers can offer competitive, caring coverage.
At McIver Insurance Inc., we specialize in group benefit plans designed for 2-10 employees that grow with your business. Call now to learn more.
FAQs
Q1) Do I need to hire an HR person to manage benefits?
No. Many small businesses use benefits software or work with brokerages like McIver Insurance to handle setup and support.
Q2) What’s the difference between group insurance and an HRA?
Group insurance is a single policy covering all employees. HRAs reimburse employees for individual plans and out-of-pocket expenses.
Q3) Can I offer dental and vision without a health plan?
Yes. You can customize your package to include only the benefits you want, including dental, vision, or wellness perks on their own.